Original Graphic. Data pulled from: 1,2,4,5 Please note this figure includes chick and adult deaths. However, almost all lead poisoning and plastic ingestion death can be attributed to chicks.
I have included the table below to give some perspective on the chart above. This table(2) was produced by a study measuring long term population decline from lead-based mortality rates. Something salient from this paper is that the generalization: long-lived species demographics are more influenced by death of older aged individual, does not necessarily apply to Laysan Albatross. They have shown this in their table, where they estimate up to a 360,000 bird population decline over 50 years. This result is from just 14,000 dead chicks. If this large population change occurred from only 14,000 chicks, the 80,000-200,000 chicks that are speculated to die from plastic will have very serious consequences for the future of the Laysan Albatross population.
What I would do as a concerned researcher: There are many estimates of mortality rates for these birds, each with wide ranges. A new study needs to be done to give more accuracy to my graph above, so that studies like the one below can prove that these birds are in serious danger.
Year post clean-up | Lead mortality=3.5% before clean-up | Lead mortality=7% before clean-up | Lead mortality=14% before clean-up |
---|---|---|---|
10 | 24 860 | 49 873 | 100 389 |
20 | 46 861 | 93 196 | 184 275 |
30 | 66 252 | 130 627 | 253 801 |
40 | 83 263 | 162 765 | 310 850 |
50 | 98 103 | 190 153 | 357 080 |
I like your figure idea. It sounds clear and doable. Deniz A.
ReplyDeleteGood clear and unique graphic
ReplyDeleteI think this is a great unique graphic. I know you have a sources page, but it might be a good idea to also source specifically on this page where you got this data from. Maybe create a caption for the image and annotate it? Just a thought.
ReplyDelete-Brianna
I feel like a caption would make the figure more strong and referring back to study and explaining more about the study would make this page stronger.
ReplyDeleteKevin
agreed with above, caption and what research was done to obtain the data you use for the graphs is probs a good idea! cool plan on making the 50 years ahead projection based on current trends! It will probably be depressing but informative!
ReplyDelete